Conversations with Growers
A Grower's Story: Nestor Isaac Garcia
From agricultural lending to growing organic apples, Nestor Garcia shares his journey into farming, the lessons he's learned along the way, and his vision for the future of small family farms.
Turning a Dream Into a Farm
Nestor shares how his childhood interest in growing things led him from agricultural lending to establishing a farming operation with his father.
Prefer audio? Listen here or open the episode on Spotify →
Lessons from Farming
Nestor reflects on organic apple production, the economics of farming, raising a family, experimenting with AI, and his hopes for the future of small farms.
Prefer audio? Listen here or open the episode on Spotify →
About This Conversation
Nestor Garcia's interest in farming began as a child, planting corn in his mother's yard. That interest eventually led him to study agricultural business at BYU–Idaho, pursue a career in agricultural lending, and establish a farming operation with his father in Washington state.
In these two conversations, Nestor reflects on the opportunities that helped him get started, the challenges of learning to grow apples organically, and what he wishes he had known as a beginning farmer. He also shares his thoughts on raising children on a farm, using artificial intelligence to explore new ideas, and the economic challenges facing small fruit growers.
Underlying both conversations is Nestor's belief that there is still a place for small family farms in modern agriculture — and his desire to help preserve those opportunities for future generations.
Key Topics
- From banking to orchard ownership
- Getting started in commercial farming
- Organic apple production
- The economics of growing fruit
- Raising a family on the farm
- AI in agriculture
- The future of small family farms
Transcript: Turning a Dream Into a Farm Read transcript ↓
Scott: I know you graduated from BYU–Idaho, right? After you graduated, what did you do?
Nestor: Yes, so the year before I graduated, I got interviewed and offered a job in a banking institution here in Washington. And so we picked up the bags and moved over here and started working as an ag lender. And so I worked as an ag lender for about seven years. Three, four years into that, I started realizing that fruit growing looked fun, and it sounded like something that I wanted to do.
My dad was getting close to getting retired. He wanted to get close to the grandchildren, so we talked about it and we decided to invest in a piece of ground, which is the one that we're standing on. We started with a few other projects before, but this is the first commercial piece of ground that we purchased to start farming. By then I had a little bit of experience as to what it entails to be a fruit grower, but I started as a brand-new guy, didn't know much more than I should have been.
And so we started, we did that for a few years, and then a couple opportunities showed up to purchase more land, lease more land, and then we continued to grow. And now we're farming about 40 acres, mostly organic Cosmic Crisp, and now we're diversifying into cherries and a couple other farming projects. But in essence, what we started is going back to my dream of farming. I've always wanted to do it, so that's the reason we're doing this.
Scott: I know you grew up, or you were born in Venezuela, and then spent part of your childhood in Mexico.
Nestor: Yes. Yes.
Scott: And then you studied agriculture. When you were younger, what kind of ag did you eventually see yourself going into?
Nestor: When I was younger, I always had an affinity for farming and growing things. My mom would always remind me and [unclear] because I would plant corn seeds in the yard, and she'll have corn stalks in the middle of the grass and get upset at me. And so I always had a passion and a love for growing things. And so I went to school to study ag business.
I focused in global food production because I had experience in other countries. But then my original dream was to get involved with greenhouse production. I always found fascinating the hydroponic systems and fully enclosed growing systems. But as I started studying and learning other options, I realized that conventional farming looked more in line with what I wanted to do.
Once I started actually doing some farm internships and a couple opportunities to work in the farming world, I realized that I didn't want to work 15 hours a day for somebody else. And so that's why I went through the ag business part of it and eventually did banking. When the opportunity showed up to do my own farms, then it made more sense to spend the hours and the energy and the sacrifice to do our own little venture.
Scott: When you were talking about you and your dad buying an orchard, tell me the story about how everything just lined up for you guys to have that opportunity.
Nestor: Yeah. Yeah. I look back and I think it was providential the way that we got into our farms because I was doing my job as a banker and then the friend of a friend told me, "Hey, there's somebody leasing an orchard." And I met with the owner, told him what I was doing and it was between me, somebody that was brand new and had nothing to do with agriculture and an established farmer.
So we were competing to lease that ground and the owner decided to give me a shot and lease me that farm just because he saw the vision of what I was trying to achieve, which is looking for the next niche, looking for the next opportunity to improve efficiencies and make more money on what we have going on. And so he liked that philosophy and gave me a shot.
Once that happened, this property came for sale. This happened to be a former client of mine that wanted to buy property and ended up not buying it. And then he calls me and he said, "Hey, I'm having some family problems. I'm going to move out to the East Coast. Do you know who might be interested in buying this orchard that I just planted?" And I said, "I want to do it."
I can attribute a lot of the opportunity that we've had to the USDA. Honestly, it's a big shout out to them. Anybody that wants to be a small farmer, the first thing they talk to is the FSA. I wouldn't be here without their financial support offering me loans and programs that allow me to purchase these properties and obviously our banking partners as well.
But everything lined up, honestly. I look back and I think to myself, I was blessed that people were brave enough to give me a shot at it and let me borrow as much money as I did because it is very capital intensive to grow apples and to purchase a piece of ground with apples. But we've been blessed to have success here and there and stay afloat and be able to pull it off, let's call it.
Transcript: Lessons from Farming Read transcript ↓
Scott: In your experience, what have been the biggest challenges you've had so far?
Nestor: Yes. I think my biggest challenge was self-imposed. When I started, I saw huge potential in the Cosmic Crisp variety. It was new. I liked how the apple performed. So I told my dad, "We should invest in this." I think there's huge potential for it. But I saw, again, a niche in the market where I thought, "A lot of people are gonna plant this variety, but not a lot of people are gonna go into the organic market because conventionally they should pay well for the first few years."
So we decided to start farming as an organic grower with no knowledge on how to do either one, except for what we just read and whatnot. So my biggest challenge was the learning curve of how to grow a commercially viable crop under organic management practices without knowing what we're getting into.
Scott: Not only were you a new grower, but you were just learning about organic growing.
Nestor: Correct. Just learning how to grow apples, that's like a lifelong enterprise. So learning how to do that and organic, that's my biggest self-imposed issue. Managing pests, including codling moth, was the biggest challenge. Nutrient management, crop load, water, stress. All the things that you handle with it. The fact that you have to produce just as good-looking fruit in organic as it is conventional. All those things were things that I wasn't aware of.
Scott: And when you think about organic fruit, you kind of think about a little bit of imperfect fruit. Like, not as much, like heirloom-type, misshapen.
Nestor: Yes. However, on the commercial side of things, that's not true. They have the same quality standards as conventional. And so, there were some roadblocks we had to go through. Aside from that, like any other farmer, increasing input costs, limited labor, access to financing. All those things have been hard things to go through throughout the last eight years we've been doing this.
Scott: What do you know now that you have learned along the way that you wish you did when you first started?
Nestor: Good question. I wish I would have planted a little more cherries from the get-go than I did apples. Apples provide, in my opinion, a little bit more stability, which if you show that to any farmer, they'll laugh. Apples have been very volatile. But when I was a banker and I started to invest into agriculture, apples provided a much more stable first-time investment than cherries.
The one thing that nobody tells you as a beginning apple farmer is the cash flow cycle of apples is extremely long. There is no thing like that on earth, where you are expected to float a business for about a year and a half before you get a full cycle of the cash flow of your fruit. That was the one thing that somebody would have told me.
Scott: Tell me a little bit about your kids. What are their interests? Do they have the passion for growing?
Nestor: Yes, yes. My kids are lovely. I have four kids. My youngest is six. My oldest is 13 this year. I have two daughters in the middle. One is 11 and one is nine, turning 10. They all love to come to the farm. They all hate to work in the farm, but I get them involved. Every time there is planting time, they love to come and stomp on the trees when we plant them. They love to come and support whenever they can.
Like my father, I don't intend or wish to impose upon them the love of farming. If you have it and you want to do it, then we have a place for you to nurture that love. But if you don't and you have another interest, then I'm not going to push that on them.
Scott: How have you been finding AI beneficial in your orchard?
Nestor: I use it significantly. As you can imagine, a lot of my ideas are out of these realms of conventional wisdom. So I can't tell you how many times I've told my ideas to people, and the first thing is, "You're crazy."
Scott: But the crazy ideas are usually the ones that...
Nestor: Sometimes. Sometimes. Ten out of 20, no, ten out of 15 ideas that I produce don't work, but one or the other five might work. And so, ChatGPT, for example, has been a phenomenal tool and I'm very specific to it.
Okay, how can I manage heat loss in this block? How can I improve heat retention, air flow and this, this and that? I'm thinking about using a hydroponic system coupled with this, this and that. ChatGPT can tell me all its thoughts. Sometimes I'm like, "You don't know what you're talking about." But other times it brings up things that I'm like, "Oh, I didn't know that." And so, it's helped me a lot to kind of shoot holes into my ideas and build a more established framework on what I want to do.
Scott: It's like having a consultant without having to pay a consultant.
Nestor: Yes.
Scott: You have a monthly fee if you want the...to upgrade. Yeah. Like you said, it's an amazing learning tool.
Nestor: It is. And what I like the most about it is how positive it is, even though it can be naive. Meaning, I've talked to consultants and oftentimes I find them skeptical. And I find them opinionated in the sense of, "It's not going to work." Whereas AI is oftentimes thinking, "That's a wonderful idea. You're on the right track. Let's keep going. I'm glad you thought about that."
And so it makes me feel encouraged. I'm like, "Okay, I'm not so crazy." Oftentimes, it tells me, "I see some roadblocks ahead of this, but let's go through them." And so, nothing wrong about consultants. I love them. I use them. But AI is nice. AI is nicer. And so, in a world where everybody's telling me, "It's not going to work. You shouldn't do it. Don't invest in it. You're going to fail," having even a robot tell me, "You're on the right track," gives me courage, you know?
Farming is becoming increasingly extremist in the sense of who farms. And small farmers are becoming extinct because of a problem of economics. The larger you are, the more efficient you are, the more cost-effective, and the more capital you have to invest in new technologies.
Small farmers, I've noticed, they're getting stuck with older systems and older ways to do things, and sadly, old mentalities of doing things. And so I keep encouraging farmers, look and think outside the box. Think about things that big farmers can't do and do them to stay current and vigilant. And so I'm trying to find ways like that that I can make sure my operation is viable long-term, even as a small grower.
Scott: When my wife and I entered the industry in 2008, we had a lot of small to mid-sized growers. All gone.
Nestor: All gone, yeah. And there's nothing negative to say about large corporations. They're magnificent. They know what they're doing. But on the opposite note, there is something about farming that just... We're meant to do it. We're meant to grow things. It's part of our nature to build and to grow things.
And to say that because we have large corporation farmers, then that removes the opportunity for small farmers to come into the industry. I don't want to believe that we're there yet.
And so if I can find ways for small farmers to get into the industry because of new ways to do things, then that's the mark I want to leave on the earth. I think if I can look back when I'm old and say, "Hey, you helped ten farmers stay alive and pass on to the next generation because of what you did," I could die happy. That would be the best feeling for sure.
Scott: That's awesome. Thank you, Nestor.
Nestor: Yeah, of course.
More Conversations with Nestor Garcia
STAY IN THE LOOP
More Conversations and Growing Guides
If you'd like to hear about new grower interviews and Growing Guides, leave your email below.
We'll email you when new conversations or guides are published.